U.S. vs. Ellis Buck, Sam Brenner, Viola Doss, et al.: Memorandum Opinion and Orders


Memorandum opinion and orders dealing with demurrers and motions to squash, pleas in abatement and motions to strike such pleas in abatement in Criminal Cases Nos. 13646, 13648, and 13650. Due to the similarities of the cases, only No. 13646 is addressed in detail. The demurrers and motions to squash argue about what and how voters' rights are violated when counts are switched from the intended candidate to another vs. simply not being counted, whether citizens indeed possess a right to vote for members of Congress, the level of detail included in the describtion of the charges, and other potential issues with the indictments as written. District Judge Merrill E. Otis overrules these arguments. The pleas in abatement are based on a claim that Judge Albert L. Reeves was "intemperate, inflammatory, argumentative, prejudicial" to the grand jury that returned the indictments. Judge Otis writes that there is nothing to justify the idea that the grand jurors acted "only as a group of puppets, robbed of their reason" in bringing the indictments, and that the pleas should be overruled.

Date Created
Modern Location
Kansas City, MO
Collection Title, Call or Box Number
NARA ID 573453, Criminal Case Files, 1879 - 1987
Rights Statement

Publication, commercial use, or reproduction of this image or the accompanying data requires prior written permission from the National Archives at Kansas City. Use of this image also requires that credit be given to the National Archives at Kansas City.

Digital Object Identifier